I was reading a post today over at the Broadstuff blog written by Alan Patrick where he was discussing an earlier post by Fred Wilson about comment fragmentation – which is becoming one of the more hot topics out there in the blogosphere. Again the main culprit for this fragmentation is FriendFeed because of our ability to comment about someone’s post there instead of on the actual blog. The feeling is that this is breaking down the lines of conversation and taking the originating site out of the loop.
The other culprit that some folks like to point fingers at as well is Disqus which is third party commenting platform that a growing number of bloggers are using. The reason being here is that the comments are basically on the Disqus servers and out of the bloggers control and when combined with FriendFeed (Disqus is one of the services that FriendFeed lets you pull in) whole conversations can take place without having to go anywhere near the originating blog.
Well the obvious solution right off the bat here is for Disqus to add write back abilities to their API so that any comments added in FriendFeed to the Disqus thread there would also show up on the blog. Now I know that they are working on adding this ability but I don’t think it can come soon enough personally.
However there is one idea that as wacky as it might sound could be a partial solution to this comment fragmentation but only really if you were running WordPress. Yup .. that’s my suggestion WordPress should acquire Disqus and make it an integral part of the WordPress installation; both on WordPress.com and self-hosted installations.
Now before you fall to the floor laughing at this crazy old fart think it through for a moment. The reason I suggest Disqus over its competitors is that it is drop dead simple to use which is in keeping with the whole idea of WordPress. Disqus already has an available API and only needs to add the write back capabilities into it and all kinds of social type sites would be able to hook into it – which opens up all kinds of possibilities I am sure.
Doing this would also solve the problem of our comments not being on our own blogs along with cutting down on a lot of the comment fragmentation that is going on. This could work as well with IntenseDebate but their comment interface is a lot more complicated that the one from Disqus and may prove difficult to integrate into a WordPress code base as it goes against the simplicity of WordPress. It wouldn’t work with sezWho as far as I can tell because their product just sits on top of the existing WordPress comment system and besides like they said today they are more interested in the reputation angle of comment makers.
So yes this is a completely wacky idea I don’t deny it but a lot stranger ideas have taken hold and actually happened – why not this one?
Hey, like this post? Why not share it with a buddy?
Recent Comments