Shooting at Bubbles

taking joy in the popping of the social media bubble & other web 2.0 silliness

  • Home
  • Archives
  • Contact
  • About
Twitter Facebook RSS
Tag Archives: A-List

Blogging is just modern day commentary

Posted on January 24, 2007 by Steven Hodson
2 Comments

Just in from TechCrunch we have the following.... As I was going through my midmorning read of feeds I was struck by how little real technology news is continually available. hmm let me rephrase that a little bit. There is a lot technology news out there but it comes to us through a very small blogging channel and the rest of the blogosphere is nothing but commentary on that news.

Even the majority of A-List bloggers from what I can tell are just higher profile commentators with probably about 5 to 10% of them being the actual originators of news. These are the folks that tech companies reach out to first, they are the folks you invite to launches or conferences and the one’s that show that blogging can be a profession.

This can be frustrating for some tech oriented bloggers downline from the A-List; especially if they want to be a news originator instead of just another commentary flack.

I think though that if it wasn’t for the majority of professional bloggers; commentators or not, the ride that bloggers like TechCrunch, Om Malik, Engadget or even the grandfather of RSS himself Dave Winer would not have the reach or importance they do.

It’s important to realize that even those of us who sit down day after day reading RSS feed and blogs, and then posting our thoughts about what we have read or what we think about what is happening in the technology news front have an equally important part in the blogosphere as the A-List folks.

As long as we don’t become just headline and link clippers or regurgitators of what we read then your readership will grow as readers find your blog; or feed, and like your opinion or way of interpreting the news of the day.

It’s not so bad being just a commentator; and who knows maybe the day will come when you can be a news originator – you never know what that next feed will bring your way.

Tweet
Categories: Technology | Tags: A-List, blogging, blogs, Dave Winer, Engadget, Om Malik, TechCrunch

Technorati not the only ceiling to break

Posted on December 25, 2006 by Steven Hodson
14 Comments

For bloggers the pot at the end of the rainbow is placing in the A-List of Technorati listing; or at least the high B’s, because with that comes fame and fortune. For some this is quite a literal thing and for others – well… it’s some major bragging rights. I have come to the conclusion though that this Technorati ceiling is not the only one that the Z-Listers need to break through.

After all there is Techmeme and to a slightly lesser degree; but growing, Tailrank. Both of these sites display the hot topics happening in the b’sphere on an almost real time basis and who is linking (discussing) to those topics. You get listed anywhere on the front page of either and your pageviews go up; which incidentally can lead to further downlinking which can affect your Technorati listing.

Now I semi understand how Technorati works but I really do not have a clue on how Techmeme and Tailrank figure out what goes on the main page or when other than I assume that like Technorati it is based on linking between blogs and/or news sites. Even if this is close to how it is done you can tell it is definitely those blogs with authority; as Technorati phrases it, that get any placement on Techmeme or Tailrank.

A case in point is the big story over Christmas of Jimmy (Jimbo) Wales announcing the impending project called Wikiasari that I first saw talked about in Mashable! within a very short period of time and a follow-up post from Nicolas Carr. It took me about half an hour to post my thoughts on the whole thing with proper trackbacks to Mashable! and Rough Type (but I guess Nicolas didn’t like me calling him “the Web 2.0 curmudgeon” because the trackback didn’t appear to get posted).

But if you look on Techmeme nowhere do you see any linkage to WinExtra. Like I said I don’t know how they work thing but given the fact I had posted and linked; even got a comment for Jimbo, within a very short period of time of the original posting you would think WinExtra would get placed somewhere – wouldn’t you?

The way I see it unless a blogger can break the ceiling of the Big ‘T’ Trinity of blogdom their chances of being taken seriously is next to nil. The best you can do it to keep slogging away, write about what means something to you and if you get a chance to link back to one of the top 10 of the A-List grab the chance. You never know when one of those trackbacks or links will break that ceiling for you.

 

 

 

Advertisement:  What’s Hiding in Your Download? Surf Secure with CounterSpy!

Tweet
Categories: Technology | Tags: A-List, Mashable, Rough Type, Tailrank, Techmeme, Technorati, Z-List

The Rules of Blogging

Posted on November 1, 2006 by Steven Hodson
Comments off

It never fails that as soon as we come up with a new idea it is followed shortly after by those inevitable top 10 lists of the right way to do things and the world of blogging is no different. Whether it be about the tools we use to get our thoughts and opinions to the web or how to pimp the search engines to get that almighty first page listing those top 10 lists proport to show us the way to blogging nirvana – the Technorati Top 100 (A-Listers).

We constantly tweak our pages with help gleaned from the writers of Top 10 lists thinking that they must know something the rest of us don’t. We scan our referrer logs to see where those inbound links are coming from hoping against hope that we’ve been dugged or at least been mentioned in the hallowed ground of the A-Lister’s RSS feeds. We dream of the day when we get one of those anon emails letting us be the one to first to spread some exciting; or sordid, tech news.

On the face of it this seems to be rather ridiculous but for those of us bloggers that aspire to the A-List this is just part of our daily job of writing good blog posts that hopefully will attract a growing readership. Then there are those that think that bloggers are nothing more than  little wannabe journalists and don’t deserve credibility of any kind.

In many cases this might be true as the over abundance of “my day sucks worse than yours” and the “hax0rs rule and Micro$oft sucks” is plainly evident with any Google search easily shows; but even among that verbal chaff there are those blogs that have the stuff of good  journalism right there for everyone to see.

So how does one do all the right things to get above that verbal chaff and make your blog worthy of some-one’s RSS client or browser favorites? One of the most common suggestions I have seen on these lists is find your niche. Well personally I think this suggestion sucks for being at the top of a top 10 lists. It might have been as good suggestion during the childhood of blogging but come on folks there are only so many niches available and I am pretty sure they are just about all spoken for by now. That doen’t mean it isn’t a good suggestion I just don’t think it carries the same weight it once might have.

Another of the usual top suggestions in these list is to write passionately about your chosen subject. Well DUH! … about the only ones that wouldn’t be writing passionately are those running shill blogs (splogs) where their words are paid for. The very idea of blogs is to write about things that matter to you and when something matters passion comes naturally – or at least it should.

There is one suggestion that invariably shows up in the Top 10 lists that I agree with whole heartly and that is – take responsibilty for what you post. This means that if you are proven to be wrong in what you have written be man/woman enough to say “Yup I screwed up and was wrong” and most importantly join in in the comment flow from that post. Don’t hide from it and most importantly don’t censor the comment flow – no matter how bad you may look at the time. Censoring; or turning off comments, will only make you look worse.

If there is a number one rule I think it would have to be the 5 second rule. There’s an old business axiom that first impressions are everything and those first impressions are generally made within the first five seconds of meeting some-one. Well blogs are no different – especially if you want to be taken seriously. Flowery borders and pink pastels do not a tech site make; nor does hax0r speak in white on a black background.

Anyone can write Micro$oft sux0rs – Linux rulz and have skull and crossbones fluttering in the cyber wind but would you take what they have to say seriously? Not likely and along with this; regardless of your native language, every effort should be made to elevate your writing skills so that spelling and gramatical errors don’t detract from what you are trying to say – or your credibilty to say it. I know with myself it is a hard thing to do but I am also the first one to leave a site when I see spelling errors that are so obvious it calls into question the author’s ability to impress upon me the reader that he knows what he is talking about.

The one other thing that I believe is one of the prime tenets of blogging; or at least should be, was raised in a post by Paul Stamatiou on his blog (PaulStamatiou.com). It was a lengthy post about bloggers taking time to research what they are writing before hitting the publish button. He starts out with:

One of my highest-ranked pet peeves about blogging regards bloggers who don’t take the time to do a bit of researching before posting an article. This is aimed at “A-list” bloggers more than anything. They are usually in such a hurry to beat the crowd and get something published that the accuracy and factuality of their information is left in the back seat. 

I would further this by adding – don’t add your voice to the wilderness. I see this so many times where a story (or meme in blog speak) gets started by an A-Lister and then everyone starts posting the same story or variations of it. Now I realize this is great for link jiuce but jeez just how many times to we need to read the number Firefox 2.0 downloads in one day; or that a bunch of VC’s got enormous Ajax woodies over some silly assed site is hot because it’s so Web 2.0.

The flipside of this is just the fact ma’am .. just the facts type of posts we see. Don’t be afraid to express an opinion on what you are writing about. Afterall there are thousands of blogs out there many of whom are going to be writing the exact same thing you are but what they don’t have is your opinion. If people wanted dry throated reporting of the facts then the traditional media wouldn’t be headed down the proverbial toilet the way it is. Blogs are successfull because of the author, people keep you in their RSS feeds or visit your blogs because of your personality and because they care about the way you feel on subjects.

The last thing I would strongly suggest; well actually two, is get out from behind your blog and get involved in the comment flow of those bloggers who you respect. Many a times I have seen my visitor stats spike after I have gotten involved in a conversation and those visits can be traced back to those blogs I have left comments on. As for the second of the two … follow those links and expand your pool of reference blogs.

Blogging is a job that can take many hours of a day especially if you want the recognition of being a good blogger who can be trusted so make sure to do it right from the very beginning.

Tweet
Categories: Technology | Tags: A-List, blogging, style, Technorati

Blogging respectability vs makin’ a buck

Posted on October 9, 2006 by Steven Hodson
Comments off

Recently there has been something of an uproar among the A-List bloggers concerning what is being called a blogger payola scheme started by PayPerPost.com.

The basic premise is that bloggers can join and make themselves available to advertisers; and or spammers, to write what is really nothing more than ad copy for products. In return the bloggers get paid a pittance.

As Stowe Boyd over at /Message said:

Who will be hurt? Well, we all will be, ultimately. The most well-known bloggers will reject this model. In fact, I wonder how longer it will be before someone creates a logo that we will start to use to identify ourselves as being independent of PayPerPost or any other payolaa scheme. It will be the bloggers with less-established reputations that will be damaged the most, since in a world filled with payola, readers will begin to distrust new writers recommending their favorite digital cameras or barbeque grills.

It was this statement that really crystallized something that had been bothering me – the fact that advertising networks don’t care what they feed you; or the fact that by putting ads which lead to silent installs into their ad pipelines could potentially destroy any creditability that a new and struggling blogger is trying to gain.

After all, one of the main themes of the PayPerPost debate is developing and maintaining blogger creditability. However for A-List bloggers to be arguing this is disingenuous as the only way their heavily monitzed sites; and their reps, could possibly be damaged is through the actions of Z-List bloggers (like me I guess :) ).

Unlike the A-List though we aren’t making hundreds of thousands of dollars a month from advertising or speaking engagements. No, we are left having to troll through the various ad networks hoping that we can make enough shekels a month to cover our hosting and bandwidth.

As Z-Lister’s; who are trying hard to build a rep, we hope that our chosen ad network would want us to succeed; because as we grow so does their revenue grow. So when I was informed by one of our forum members that one of the advertising links lead him to a site that tried to silently install some application I was concerned; as our forums consist of some very tech savvy people and they would not appreciate such a thing – nor would they support WinExtra if I condoned such a thing.

After assuring this member that I knew nothing about it; and confirming his report I fired off an email to AdBrite; my chosen ad network, requesting that they please look into this matter and confirm whether or not it was their policy to condone this type of ad linkage.

Five days later I finally got an email in return that basically stated in part:

If the ad is purchased as a network ad, AdBrite does manually review sites to make sure auto-insatllation, pop-ups, or illegal content are not present.

Thanks for sending the ad in question to us, I will forward it to our manual review team for reviw. [spelling is theirs]

and to date; almost a week later, I have received no other communication from them and the ad in question (Globe7 dot com) is still in rotation and still leading to a page that tries to install software without permission.

Now I can bet you that if this had happened to any of the A-List bloggers it would have taken one email and Globe7 would have been history from the rotation; but then I’m no Boyd, Cuban or Doctorow so I guess my rep doesn’t mean anything.

However what companies like AdBrite are missing is that if you ruin enough budding blogger reputations there will be a critical mass reached where even your cash cow A-Listers will feel the repercussions and by that time it may be too late to fix the situation.

In the meantime I’ll be canceling my dealings with AdBrite; and kissing my measly $5.09 earnings for the month good-bye. Maybe the next company will have a little more foresight and realize that even the future A-Listers have to start somewhere.

At least I’ll have self-respect and hopefully join the ranks of the trusted bloggers.

Tweet
Categories: Technology | Tags: A-List, AdBrite, Boyd, debate, Globe7, payola, PayPerPost, reputation, trust, Z-List
Page 6 of 6« First«...23456
  • Search posts

  • Advertising

  • Post Categories

    • Odds & Ends (600)
    • Opinion (26)
    • Podcasts (319)
    • Social (10)
    • Technology (1615)
    • Video (4)
  • Follow Me…

    Follow Us on FacebookFollow Us on TwitterFollow Us on RSSFollow Us on E-mail
  • Follow me on Google+

    Couldn't get data from google+
  • Advertising

  • Recent Posts

    • Lazy OEMs equal crap systems – thanks for nothing
    • Doing the dog paddle to the future
    • Our red/blue Facebook pill moment has arrived
    • If you are using a ghostwriter on Twitter you don’t have a clue about social media
    • Another note about this “real name” nonsense
  • Recent Comments

    • John E. Bredehoft on Our red/blue Facebook pill moment has arrived
    • Top Ten Social Media Articles and Tweets of the Day | Michael Blogs on Our red/blue Facebook pill moment has arrived
    • links for 2011-09-26 | Netweb on Our red/blue Facebook pill moment has arrived
    • Leigh on If you are using a ghostwriter on Twitter you don’t have a clue about social media
    • John E. Bredehoft on Be afraid, very afraid because for some reason someone thinks I am an influencer
    • Be afraid, very afraid because for some reason someone thinks I am an influencer | Shooting at Bubbles on Are you ready for a hot new buzz phrase?
    • Rene on Google+ moron moment – no it won’t replace your blog
    • Brett Nordquist on Google+ moron moment – no it won’t replace your blog
© Shooting at Bubbles. Proudly Powered by WordPress | Nest Theme by YChong